Retirement Savings Loophole Closed

En español | According to the Council of Economic Advisers, last year alone, a retirement savings advice loophole cost Americans $17 billion as a result of extra fees.

AARP volunteers deliver petitions to the Department of Labor.

Fortunately, the Department of Labor last week unveiled a new rule finally closing a loophole that allowed some financial experts to give advice that was in their own  interest — rather than the best interest of hardworking Americans.

Why did this loophole exist? The original guidelines for financial advice under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) were drafted 40 years ago when most workers were in employer-managed defined benefit plans and when 401(k) plans didn’t even exist. With most people and most money now in self-managed individual accounts — and retirement investment advice more critical than ever — it was time to update the rules.

Here are the some of the biggest changes made by the rule:


  • All retirement plan advisers that provide advice for a fee are subject to a “fiduciary” standard, meaning in the best interests of their customers.
  • Investment advice will apply to recommendations to take a distribution, including a rollover, and to IRAs.
  • Under new exemptions, advisers will be able to receive common forms of compensation (e.g., commissions) as long as they ensure their advice is impartial and in the best interest of their customers.
  • Firms must confirm the firm’s and the individual adviser’s status as fiduciaries; make prudent investment recommendations without regard to their own interests; charge no more than reasonable compensation; and make no misrepresentations about their recommendations.
  • Consumers must be provided key adviser information at the time of a purchase, and other important information must be maintained on the firm website or available upon request.


The rule is the culmination of a five-year effort by the Department of Labor, including a re-proposed rule, hundreds of meetings, thousands of comments, and tens of thousands of petitions. Input was received from the financial services industry, consumer groups and members of Congress, and there was a detailed impact analysis and 3½ days of hearings. This is a sweeping and important rule, and the final rule demonstrated that the department listened to the feedback it received, with improvements to the rule — such as the timing and nature of the best interest contract exemption, the amount of disclosure required, and clarifications on the exemption for education and selling. All these changes made for a stronger, more streamlined rule, while maintaining the goal of retirement advice in the best interest of those Americans who have worked so hard to save.

Americans work hard to plan and save for retirement. Bad financial advice shouldn’t be yet another barrier Americans have to worry about. This rule will protect Americans’ hard-earned money and ensure retirement investment advisers are putting their clients first.

The department’s rule goes into effect beginning in April 2017.


David Certner is the legislative counsel and legislative policy director for government affairs at AARP. Follow him on Twitter @DavidCertner for the latest updates on what’s happening in Washington on the issues that matter most to older Americans. 

Search AARP Blogs

Related Posts
December 11, 2018 10:07 AM
In an election year filled with partisanship and political fights, it’s no surprise that many Americans feel that their voices aren’t being heard or that the issues that affect their lives aren’t being addressed. But, many outstanding elected officials work hard every day to make a positive difference for their constituents.  That’s why AARP recognizes state legislators, governors, and other elected officials – from both sides of the aisle – who have stepped up and worked together to write, support, and advance common-sense policies that help older Americans remain in their homes and communities and retire with confidence. AARP is proud to announce our fifth annual bipartisan class of Capitol Caregivers, who fought this year to increase support for family caregivers and their loved ones, along with our fourth annual bipartisan class of Super Savers, who championed policies that enhance retirement security.
December 05, 2018 01:06 PM
Caroline is a mother of two children and a preschool teacher who unexpectedly became a family caregiver for her father after he suffered a major stroke. Her father, Tom, now deceased, lost the use of his right side and his ability to speak. Multiple surgeries and rehabilitation treatments later, he was able to live at home with the help of nurses. But it was up to Caroline to provide daily care, such as overseeing appointments and handling certain nursing responsibilities, like managing his medications. “I became the person my father could rely on more than anyone in the world,” Caroline said. “I became his safe place and his best friend.” In communities across the country, family caregivers like Caroline are caring for older parents, spouses and other loved ones, helping them to remain at home – where they want to be. Their tasks are done out of love and commitment, but are not easy. That’s why AARP is fighting for family caregivers and their loved ones in every state. In 2018, AARP advanced new policies to provide more help at home, flexibility at work, training, relief and more, which will benefit over 30 million family caregivers. Here are a couple highlights:
November 27, 2018 08:55 AM
A few months ago, I wrote a blog about the vital role that transportation options play in what we at AARP call “livable communities” – great places to live for people of all ages. Being able to get around is critical to earn a living, raise a family, contribute and stay connected to your community and enjoy life. And, having alternatives to getting behind the wheel of your own car is particularly important for older adults who want to stay in their homes and communities as they age.